Obligations
Data protection impact assessment (DPIA): when GDPR Article 35 requires one.
Yes, where processing is likely to result in a high risk to the rights and freedoms of natural persons. That is the condition in Article 35. Whether your AI use case, one tool used for one purpose, meets it depends on the facts.
The decision structure
Four questions, in this order.
Taking them in another order can lead you to assess the wrong processing, or to skip the assessment because the first question was never settled.
This page cannot answer the question for you. It sets out the questions that decide it. Whether an obligation attaches to a particular AI use case depends on facts specific to your organization. Your counsel decides whether your position is adequate. Nothing here is legal advice. Supervisory authorities publish their own lists of processing that requires an assessment, and those lists differ between member states.
- 1
Is this processing of personal data at all?
If not, Art. 35 is not the relevant provision, although another law may still apply. Settle this first: a tool can involve personal data through a secondary route nobody described at the start.
- 2
Who is the controller?
The obligation sits with the controller. When an AI use case involves a vendor, a platform and an internal team, decide who is controller for which processing before the later questions. It is often the main difficulty.
- 3
Does the processing meet the likely-high-risk condition?
This is the substance of the analysis. Compare the nature, scope, context and purposes of the processing with your supervisory authority’s list of operations that require an assessment. Where the list is silent, apply the published criteria.
- 4
If not, where is the record of that decision?
People often skip this question. Concluding that no assessment is required is a legitimate outcome, and you can document it. Without a dated record, that conclusion cannot be told apart from never having asked.
An overlooked outcome
A conclusion of “no” is a documented outcome.
In some AI use cases you will rightly conclude that no assessment is required. Part of the value is showing when you reached that conclusion and on what basis. A determination, the list of laws that apply to one AI use case with each cited to the provision, gives you a record either way.
You get the set of obligations.
You get the dated statement of what was assessed and found not to apply, so you can show the question was asked.
Settle it for one AI use case
Either way, you have a record.
Add the AI use case to your inventory and answer the dynamic intake form, a questionnaire that asks only what your earlier answers make relevant. Where a question offers “Not sure”, choose it: the laws that turn on that answer are flagged for your team to review, and the work keeps moving. Your workspace shows whether Art. 35 reaches the AI use case and cites what it found. If it does, the DPIA is prepared with the regulatory parts completed, for your counsel’s review. If it does not, you have the record that says so.