Skip to content
LegisGateAI Regulatory Platform

Comparing AI laws

The EU AI Act, GDPR and HIPAA ask three different questions of an AI use case.

None of the three replaces the others. Which of them reach an AI use case depends on the tool, what it is used for, where the affected people are, your industry and the data it touches.

Three laws

What each one asks.

A summary of the question each law puts to an AI use case. The provisions themselves are cited in the platform.

GDPR: is personal data processed, and who is the controller?

Where processing is likely to result in a high risk to the rights and freedoms of people, Article 35 requires a data protection impact assessment. The obligation sits with the controller. Supervisory authorities publish their own lists of processing that needs an assessment, and those lists differ between member states.

EU AI Act: how is the AI system classified, and by whom is it used?

The tier follows the use and the jurisdictions you declare, not the kind of model. The Act also calls for a fundamental rights impact assessment (Article 27) from some deployers of high-risk systems. Whether it reaches your AI use case depends on who you are and how the system is classified, and LegisGate identifies when it applies.

HIPAA: are you a covered entity or business associate, and does the AI system handle protected health information?

In our worked example, a tool that summarizes clinicians' notes (as recorded on October 7, 2026), the notes are electronic protected health information and HIPAA returned nine obligations, more than any other law there. They include a business associate agreement (45 C.F.R. § 164.504(e)), administrative safeguards (§ 164.308), technical safeguards (§ 164.312) and the minimum necessary standard (§ 164.502(b)).

Dates and status are not on this page. When a provision applies can change. Each law is listed with its status in the Intelligence Library, and the platform shows what applies to your AI use case today.

Together

They are not alternatives.

One AI use case can meet more than one of these laws, and a different AI use case in the same organization can meet different ones.

GDPR does not replace the EU AI Act

GDPR is one law among several that may apply. It does not replace sectoral law, employment law or AI-specific statutes that reach the same AI use case.

HIPAA is not the only law on health AI

In the worked example (as recorded on October 7, 2026), seven laws returned twenty-five obligations for one clinical tool, among them CMS conditions of participation, a state AI statute and California privacy law.

Country alone does not decide it

Obligations attach by where the affected people are. A US organization with European customers, applicants or employees is inside the question.

In LegisGate

How LegisGate answers it for one AI use case.

You describe the AI use case once. The determination then shows which of these laws reach it.

The laws that apply

Each law cited to the exact provision, and the laws that were checked and found not to apply, with the reason.

What each law requires

The obligations, each with an owner, a due date and the proof that it was done.

The written assessments

The DPIA, the UK DPIA and the US state privacy risk and data protection assessments are prepared from the same determination, with the regulatory parts completed for your counsel's review. For the EU AI Act, LegisGate identifies when a fundamental rights impact assessment applies.

Counsel decides. This page is not legal advice. LegisGate identifies the laws and cites them. Your counsel decides whether your position is sufficient.

Questions

Common questions.

Does GDPR replace the EU AI Act?

No. They are separate laws with separate obligations, and the EU AI Act applies only where the AI use case falls within it. GDPR does not replace AI-specific statutes or sectoral law that reach the same AI use case.

Does HIPAA apply to an AI tool?

It depends on who you are and what the tool handles. In our worked example of a tool that summarizes clinicians' notes, as recorded on October 7, 2026, the notes are electronic protected health information, and HIPAA returned nine obligations for the tool.

Is a DPIA required for every AI use case?

No. Article 35 of the GDPR applies where processing is likely to result in a high risk to the rights and freedoms of people, whether or not AI is involved. Whether your AI use case meets that condition depends on the facts.

Which of these laws applies to my AI use case?

That depends on the AI use case: the tool, what it is used for, where the affected people are, your industry and the data it touches. Add it to LegisGate and the determination shows the laws that apply, each cited, and the ones that were checked and ruled out.

Begin

See which of these reach one AI use case.

Add an AI use case to your inventory and answer the intake form. The determination shows the laws that apply and what each requires.

Talk to usWe're here to help
EU AI Act, GDPR and HIPAA for AI: What Each Asks | LegisGate