Skip to content
LegisGateAI Regulatory Platform

Impact assessments

Which impact assessment does an AI use case need?

Several laws call for a written assessment, under different names. Which one applies depends on the AI use case, not on the tool alone, and a conclusion that none applies is a legitimate outcome if you record it.

The assessments

Five assessments you may meet.

LegisGate prepares the first four with the regulatory parts completed. The fifth it identifies.

EU data protection impact assessment (DPIA)

GDPR Article 35, where processing is likely to result in a high risk to the rights and freedoms of people. Prepared against the statutory requirements while the EDPB's own template remains a draft.

UK data protection impact assessment

UK GDPR Article 35, filled into the ICO's own sample template.

California privacy risk assessment

The privacy risk assessment required under California's privacy law.

Data protection assessments under other state privacy laws

The data protection assessments required under other U.S. state privacy laws.

Fundamental rights impact assessment (FRIA)

EU AI Act Article 27. LegisGate identifies when it applies. The FRIA document itself is prepared once the official template is published.

How to tell

Four questions, in this order.

Work through them in this order. These are the questions for a DPIA; the state assessments and the FRIA turn on their own conditions.

  1. Is this processing of personal data at all?

    If not, Article 35 is not the relevant provision, although another law may still apply. A tool can involve personal data through a route nobody described at the start.

  2. Who is the controller?

    The obligation sits with the controller. When an AI use case involves a vendor, a platform and an internal team, decide who is controller for which processing first.

  3. Does the processing meet the likely-high-risk condition?

    Compare the nature, scope, context and purposes of the processing with your supervisory authority's list of operations that require an assessment. Those lists differ between member states. Where that list is silent, apply the published criteria.

  4. If not, where is the record of that decision?

    Concluding that no assessment is required is a legitimate outcome. Without a dated record, that conclusion cannot be told apart from never having asked.

A DPIA is not only for AI. Article 35 applies to high-risk processing of personal data whether or not AI is involved. Of the written assessments, only the fundamental rights impact assessment under the EU AI Act is specific to AI.

Who does what

The regulatory part is prepared. Your team brings the judgment.

LegisGate brings the regulatory intelligence and the intake. You bring the privacy and legal judgment for your use case and organization.

Prepared from the law

The regulatory material, cited to the provisions that apply and tied to the AI use case. It is read-only, for your counsel's review.

Completed by your organization

What your processing actually involves, the safeguards, risks and mitigations, and the decisions and professional judgment. Your input stays visibly separate from the prepared material.

Questions

Common questions.

Which impact assessments can the law require for an AI use case?

The EU DPIA and UK DPIA under Article 35 of the GDPR and UK GDPR, the privacy risk assessment under California's privacy law, data protection assessments under other US state privacy laws, and, for some deployers of high-risk systems, the fundamental rights impact assessment under Article 27 of the EU AI Act.

Is a FRIA required for every AI system?

No. Article 27 calls for a fundamental rights impact assessment from some deployers of high-risk systems. Whether it reaches your AI use case depends on who you are and how the system is classified. LegisGate identifies when it applies.

Does LegisGate prepare the FRIA?

It identifies when an EU AI Act fundamental rights impact assessment applies. The FRIA document itself is prepared once the official template is published.

Can software complete the assessment for me?

It can prepare the regulatory part: which law applies, what it requires and where it is cited. Your organization supplies the facts, the analysis, the approvals and the legal conclusions, and your counsel decides whether the result is sufficient.

Begin

Find out which assessment your AI use case needs.

If the law calls for a supported assessment, it opens in your workspace with the regulatory parts completed, for your counsel's review.

Talk to usWe're here to help
AI Impact Assessments: Which One Do You Need? | LegisGate